Understanding the Difference Between Technical Services and Technical Consultancy under the Income Tax Act

In business, the terms “Technical Services” and “Technical Consultancy” are often used interchangeably. But under the Income Tax Act, 1961, and through judicial interpretations, these two carry distinct meanings—especially when it comes to the rate of Tax Deduction at Source (TDS) under Section 194J.

Let’s break it down.

The Core Difference

Aspect	Technical Services	Technical Consultancy
Nature of Work	Application-oriented, hands-on. Execution of a technical task using expertise.	Advisory, intellectual. Providing advice, solutions, designs, or plans.
Focus	On doing and delivering an output.	On planning and recommending.
Key Question	"Are you performing the technical task for me?"	"Can you analyze my problem and tell me how to do it?"
TDS Rate (u/s 194J)	2%	10%

---

Legal Context

Section 194J requires TDS on certain payments, including:

1. Fees for Professional Services
2. Fees for Technical Services
3. Royalty
4. Director remuneration (not relevant here)

The catch:

• “Fees for Technical Services (FTS)” is defined in Section 9(1)(vii) and includes managerial, technical, and consultancy services.
• But for TDS rates, consultancy is separated out as professional services (10%), while execution-based technical services fall under 2%.

---

How Courts Distinguish the Two

Courts have emphasized substance over terminology. What matters is the scope of work and actual activity performed.

If the provider is:

✅ Giving analysis, designs, feasibility reports, or opinions
✅ Advising without implementing the advice
👉 It’s Technical Consultancy → TDS @ 10%

Examples (10% TDS):

• Architect designing a building
• Financial consultant preparing a valuation report
• IT consultant recommending software
• Engineer conducting feasibility studies

---

If the provider is:

✅ Running tests, maintaining systems, or operating equipment
✅ Delivering technical outputs through direct action
👉 It’s Technical Services → TDS @ 2%

Examples (2% TDS):

• Lab technician conducting tests
• Plant operation/maintenance services

---

Practical Steps for Businesses

1. Review the Contract
• Words like advise, study, recommend, design → likely Consultancy (10%)
• Words like operate, maintain, run, test, manage → likely Service (2%)
2. Check the Invoice
• “Consultancy/Advisory Fees” → 10%
• “Technical Support/Service Charges” → 2%
3. Apply the Implementation Test
• Delivering a plan → Consultancy (10%)
• Executing the plan → Technical Service (2%)

---

Conservative Approach

If a contract has both elements, deduct at 10%.

• Why? Deducting lower and being reclassified can attract interest & penalties.
• The service provider can always claim a refund for excess TDS.

---

Final Word

The difference between Technical Services and Technical Consultancy under Section 194J is subtle but important. Always check: Is the provider advising or actually doing the work? That one question often gives you the answer.

Disclaimer: This article is for general understanding. Each case depends on its facts. Always consult a tax advisor or chartered accountant before making final decisions.