High Court: Interest Refund Allowed on Subsequent Realisation of Export Proceeds
In Ernst and Young LLP v. UOI (2026-VIL-1215-P&H), the Punjab & Haryana High Court held that interest paid under Rule 96A is refundable when export proceeds are subsequently realized.
The taxpayer had exported services under a Letter of Undertaking (LUT) but failed to realize export proceeds within the prescribed one-year period. Consequently, it paid IGST along with interest under Rule 96A(1)(b). After the export proceeds were eventually realized, the department refunded the tax but denied the refund of interest relying on Para 4.6 of Circular No. 197/09/2023-GST.
The Court observed that Section 54(1) permits refund of tax as well as interest paid on such tax. Since Rule 96A does not prohibit refund of interest on subsequent realization of proceeds, the circular could not impose a restriction beyond the Act and Rules. The Court reiterated that interest is compensatory in nature and follows the principal amount. Accordingly, the restriction contained in Para 4.6 of the circular was struck down to that extent.
While the ruling correctly enforces the principle that a circular cannot override statutory provisions, it also raises an unresolved issue: Rule 96A itself does not expressly provide for refund of tax after delayed realization, unlike Rule 96B applicable to goods exports. Nevertheless, the judgment provides significant relief to service exporters facing delayed foreign exchange realization.