Tuesday, 24 September 2024

Taxation of Transfer Fees in Co-operative Housing Societies: An Examination of the Principle of Mutuality

 1. Understanding Co-operative Housing Societies

A co-operative housing society (hereinafter referred to as ‘Society’) includes all types of societies, whether residential, commercial, or industrial. These societies are formed to collectively manage the affairs of a community, typically focusing on maintaining common amenities, property management, and ensuring shared responsibilities among members.

The functioning of these societies hinges on contributions from members towards common expenses, ensuring the upkeep of shared spaces and services. One key mode of collecting such contributions is through the transfer fee.

2. Transfer Fee: A Mechanism for Common Contributions

A transfer fee is a specific form of contribution collected by a Society when a member transfers their flat, office, or unit to another person. It represents an event-triggered contribution from the member and is aimed at maintaining and improving common services for the overall welfare of the society.

Unlike regular maintenance charges, which are periodic, the transfer fee is linked to specific instances—namely, the sale or transfer of ownership by a member. It is therefore an essential mechanism for collecting contributions to fund the common expenses of the Society.

3. Transfer Fee as a Mutual Contribution

By its very nature, the transfer fee is not a revenue-generating transaction but a form of contribution from members. This fee is utilized for the common benefit of all members and contributes towards the broader objectives of the Society, such as maintenance, repairs, and improvements of common areas and services. It helps sustain the collective infrastructure of the Society, ensuring its smooth functioning for all its members.

The transfer fee reflects the collective ownership and shared responsibility inherent in co-operative societies. Since it directly supports the common good, the fee does not result in a profit or income for the Society, but instead, strengthens the mutual welfare framework that co-operatives are built upon.

4. The Principle of Mutuality in Income Tax Law

The principle of mutuality is a core concept in income tax law, particularly concerning entities like clubs, societies, and associations. This principle asserts that when a group of people come together to form a mutual association, where contributors and beneficiaries are the same, no taxable income is generated because one cannot make a profit by dealing with oneself.

This principle applies to co-operative societies, where members contribute to a common pool for mutual benefit. The fundamental argument is that transactions between members of the Society are not considered income-generating for tax purposes since they are part of the same entity.

5. Supreme Court Ruling in ITO vs. Venkatesh Premises Co-operative Society Ltd.

The Supreme Court of India, in the case of ITO vs. Venkatesh Premises Co-operative Society Ltd. [2018] 402 ITR 670 (SC), decisively settled the application of the principle of mutuality to transfer fees in co-operative societies. The Court affirmed that:

"The doctrine of mutuality, based on common law principles, is premised on the theory that a person cannot make a profit from himself. An amount received from oneself, therefore, cannot be regarded as income and taxable."

This ruling reinforced the idea that amounts received by a Society from its members—whether through transfer fees or other contributions—cannot be considered income since the Society and its members are not separate entities for this purpose.

6. Application of the Principle of Mutuality to Transfer Fees

In light of the Supreme Court's ruling and the established principle of mutuality, it can be conclusively stated that the transfer fee received by a co-operative housing society from a member is not liable to tax under the Income Tax Act.

The transfer fee is simply a mutual contribution, used for the common benefit of all members, without resulting in any profit or income for the Society. Hence, the principle of mutuality fully governs the taxation treatment of transfer fees, ensuring that such amounts remain outside the purview of income tax.


Conclusion

The principle of mutuality plays a pivotal role in determining the taxability of contributions received by co-operative societies. Transfer fees, being a mutual contribution from members, do not amount to taxable income. The Supreme Court's ruling in the Venkatesh Premises case has provided legal clarity, confirming that transfer fees collected by societies from their members are not subject to tax under the Income Tax Act, as they are inherently non-income transactions.

No comments:

CBDT issues second round of frequently asked questions in relation to Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme, 2024

  This Tax Alert summarizes Circular No. 19/2024 dated 16 December 2024 (VSV 2- December Circular) issued by the Central Board of Direct Tax...