SC upholds HC rulings
giving retrospective effect to Finance Act, 2010 amendment that relaxed the
rigours of Sec. 40(a)(ia), providing that all TDS made during the previous year
can be deposited with the Government by the due date of filing the return of income;
Rejects Revenue's argument for a 'plain'/literal reading of the amendment,
notes carefully both the Finance Act 2008 & 2010 amendments; SC observes
that while the Finance Act, 2008 amendment (amended retrospectively w.e.f
1.4.2005 ) gave relief in cases where TDS had been deducted in the month of
March but deposited before due date of filing return, the Finance Act, 2010
amendment (applicable from AY 2010-11) extended this relief to TDS deducted in
the earlier 11 months as well and deposited before the return filing due date;
SC, on perusal of the Memorandum explaining the reasons behind the Sec.
40(a)(ia) amendment, observes that the same came with a purpose of ensuring tax
compliance, not to punish the assessee and hence the same should not be allowed
to be converted into an 'iron rod' provision which metes out stern punishment
and results in malevolent results; SC holds " A proviso which is inserted
to remedy unintended consequences and to make the provision workable, a proviso
which supplies an obvious omission in the Section, is required to be read into
the Section to give the Section a reasonable interpretation and requires to be
treated as retrospective in operation so that a reasonable interpretation can
be given to the Section as a whole..." ; Court justifies this liberal
interpretation citing the adverse consequences on 'marginal' and 'medium'
taxpayers if the amendment is not given retrospective operation; Relies on
co-ordinate bench ruling in Allied Motors (P) Limited case wherein Sec. 43B proviso
was held as retrospective in nature:SC
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Expenses Where Taxpayers May Revisit Their GST ITC Eligibility
Lease of Land ITC is blocked on goods and services used for construction of immovable property. However, land itself is not used for constru...
-
A new website launched for TDS related matters www.tdscpc.gov.in TRACES – T DS R econciliation A nalysis and C orrection E nabling S yste...
-
Slump sale is transfer of one or more business undertakings for a lump sum consideration, without assigning individual values to the each...
-
Key features of File Validation Utility (FVU) version 3.3 FVU 3.3 will be applicable for quarterly TDS/ TCS statements pertaining to...
-
CIT vs. The Instalment Supply Ltd (Delhi High Court) The assessee bought 1614 items of computer systems for Rs.40 lacs from HCL Hewlett ...
-
Facts The applicant („A‟) is a closely held Public Limited company incorporated in India in the year 1953. A‟s shareholder included A (...
-
In a recent informal guidance letter, SEBI clarified whether a cousin of a Promoter Group member qualifies as a person ‘related to promote...
-
01. TDS u/s 194J is required to be done for Royalty also w.e.f 13-7-2006. 02. Royalty had been defined under explanation 2 of se...
-
The benefit of interest free loan or loan at concessional rate of interest is given to an employee (or to any member of his household) is ...
-
Until now, 'Samaritans' is not how the Independent Directors are purported by Clause 49 in the Listing agreement. An Independ...
-
Facts Centrica India Offshore Private Limited (CIO), an Indian Company, is a wholly owned subsidiary of Centrica Plc, UK Centrica Plc a...
No comments:
Post a Comment