Wednesday, 18 November 2026

SC holds solar power generating systems as movable property and rejects mandatory applicability of 70:30 valuation for the period prior to 1 January 2019

 This Tax Alert summarizes a recent Supreme Court (SC) judgement on applicability of 70:30 ratio for valuation of goods and services w.r.t supply and installation of solar power generating systems (SPG systems) during the period 1 July 2017 to 31 December 2018.


The key findings in the SC ruling are:

  • The 70:30 ratio for valuation of goods and services applied prospectively from 1 January 2019. Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST only gave assessees an option to adopt it for the earlier period; applying the ratio compulsorily to assessees who had not chosen that option was patently erroneous and unsustainable.
  • The petitioner’s payment of GST at 5% on the supply and installation of SPG systems before 1 January 2019 was in keeping with the GST Council’s recommendations at its 14th and 15th meetings and the Government policy to promote renewable energy production.
  • Every composite supply does not qualify as a works contract. The petitioner’s SPG systems, attached to civil foundations for stability and capable of being detached and used elsewhere, were not immovable property. Their supply and installation did not constitute a works contract.
  • The nature and object of annexation, intention of the parties, functionality, permanency and marketability determine whether SPG systems are movable or immovable property.
  • Invocation of extended limitation under Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 was unsustainable. Fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts could not be imputed to the petitioner for not applying the 70:30 ratio to transactions before its introduction.
Comments:

a. Recognition of solar power generation plants as movable property may help substantially reduce ITC disputes arising from allegations that such installations constitute immovable property.

b. While the SC rejected mandatory retrospective applicability of 70:30 valuation mechanism, it did not address its validity, thereby, leaving the applicable effective GST rate post-amendment debatable.

c. The ruling strengthens challenges to Section 74 invocation in interpretational disputes; however, extended limitation may survive where deliberate withholding or misrepresentation of material facts exists.

No comments:

SC holds solar power generating systems as movable property and rejects mandatory applicability of 70:30 valuation for the period prior to 1 January 2019

  This Tax Alert summarizes a recent Supreme Court (SC) judgement on applicability of 70:30 ratio for valuation of goods and services w.r.t ...