Saturday, 25 February 2017

ITAT: Investment vs. stock-in-trade distinction irrelevant for Sec 14A application; Disallows expenditure on strategic investments

Chennai ITAT upholds Sec 14A disallowance for AYs 2011-12 & 2012-13 in respect of strategic investments made by assessee-company in subsidiary / associate companies for business purposes;  ITAT clarifies that the holding of asset/property under reference either as an investment or as stock-in-trade becomes inconsequential or irrelevant for Sec 14A application,  what is relevant is not the object for which the investment was made, but the nature of income – tax-exempt or otherwise, that arises from the investment;  Remarks that “Now, it stands to reason that if ‘investments’ forming part of the assessee’s stock-in-trade does not preclude application of sec. 14A, investments made for business, i.e., assuming so, would surely not.”; Further rejects assessee’s stand that no expenditure was incurred for making strategic investments, remarks that “the very fact that the assessee claims it as having business implications, makes such a review imperative, entailing cost.”, upholds disallowance of indirect expenditure as per Rule 8D(iii) ; Relies on Special Bench ruling in Daga Capital Management P. Ltd., Mumbai ITAT ruling in DH Securities (P.) Ltd., Bombay HC ruling Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. and Calcutta HC ruling in Dhanuka & Sons, differs from co-ordinate bench ruling in EIH Associated Hotels Ltd.  in as much as the same was without reference to the language of the provision and the aforesaid decisions:ITAT 

No comments:

Expenses Where Taxpayers May Revisit Their GST ITC Eligibility

Lease of Land ITC is blocked on goods and services used for construction of immovable property. However, land itself is not used for constru...