Bombay
HC upholds recovery of Local Body Tax (‘LBT’) on SIM cards and recharge
coupons / vouchers brought into municipal limits by telecom service provider,
u/s 127(2)(aaa) r/w Section 152-P of Maharashtra Municipal Corporations Act,
1949 (‘Act’); Rejects assessee’s reliance on SC rulings in BSNL and Idea
Mobile Communication Ltd. to contend that SIM cards and recharge coupons are
not goods, with no intrinsic value at all and incapable of being used
independent of cell phone; Perusing the relevant provisions of said Act, HC
observes that concepts of Sales Tax and LBT are not same, “LBT can be levied
on the goods brought within the limits of a Municipal Corporation even if the
same are not sold, but the same are brought either for consumption or use.”
States that SIM cards and recharge vouchers are tangible goods capable of
being transferred, stored, possessed, and used after being brought into
limits of city and hence, will be “goods” within the meaning of Section 2(25)
of said Act; While Apex Court in Idea Mobile Communication Ltd had come to
the conclusion that no sales tax is payable as SIM cards have no intrinsic
value, it had not considered whether they are capable of being used which is
relevant consideration for charging LBT, observes HC; However, HC remarks
that e-recharges, which are nothing but electronic downloads, can by no
stretch of imagination be said to be capable of being brought into limits of
a city and are not covered by Item No. 133 of Govt. Notification dated March
28, 2013; In view thereof, observes, “E-recharge is capable of being used.
But it cannot be said that by downloading erecharge through internet, e-recharge
is brought into limits of a Municipal Corporation. Hence, LBT cannot be
recovered on erecharge.” : Bombay HC
The judgment was delivered by Justice A. S. Oka and Justice
Vibha Kankanwadi.
Mr. Surel S. Shah alongwith Mr. Amitt Khairnar , Mr. Amit
Dande and Mr. Taufia Kapadia appeared on behalf of the assessee, while
Revenue was represented by Mr. N. R. Bubna and Mr. A. A. Alaspurkar.
Detailed summary will be uploaded on the portal shortly.
[TS-286-HC-2017(BOM)-VAT] Click here to read and download Judgment copy. Click here to post your comment. For subscriptions, please contact: sales@taxsutra.com |
Wednesday 4 October 2017
SIM cards & recharge vouchers constitute 'goods' for LBT, but e-recharges outside ambit
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
HC quashes Customs Instruction mandating review of MOOWR licenses granted for solar power generation
This Tax Alert summarizes a recent judgement of the Delhi High Court (HC) [1] dealing with the validity of the Instruction [2] insofar a...
-
Particulars in Part 1 and Part 2 of Step-2 of registration form are required to be exactly the same as reported in the TDS statement. Plea...
-
1. Introduction: Every trust/charitable society/ NGO that wishes to claim the tax exemption benefits has to file Form 10A to seek fresh re...
-
This article talks about important rules for buyers who are registered under GST to follow when they claim Input Tax Credit (ITC). Here ar...
-
LEASE-DEED (A brief Introduction) Lease defined. A lease of immovable property is a transfer of a right to enjoy such property, mad...
-
The circular of the Board dt. 28.06.1965 No. 17 (XL-36), provides for inspection fees and fees for certified copies of assessment and...
-
NECESSITY : Sometimes, in view of the expansion of the business, multiple increase in turnover and need for getting finances from the ...
-
Filing income tax returns (ITR) within the specified timelines under the Income-tax Act is not just a legal obligation but also crucial fo...
-
This Tax Alert summarizes a recent instruction issued by the SEZ Division, Department of Commerce, clarifying various concerns relating t...
-
On 25 April 2024, the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka delivered a judgement (W.P. No.18486/2012 and others) striking down the special prov...
No comments:
Post a Comment