HC allows HDFC Bank’s writ
petition, quashes AO’s order and subsequent reference to TPO alleging that
certain related party transactions [purchase of loans from HDFC ltd,
payment for rendering services to HBL Global and interest payment to HDB
Welfare Trust] were Specified Domestic Transactions (SDTs) u/s 92BA; Holds
that loans purchased by assessee/ petitioner from its promoter (HDFC Ltd) does
not fall within the meaning of SDT u/s 92BA(i) as HDFC Ltd does not have
‘substantial interest’ in assessee & is therefore not a ‘person’ as
contemplated in Sec 40A(2)(b)(iv); Explains that 2 conditions have to be
fulfilled for a person to have ‘substantial interest’ as contemplated in
Explanation to Sec 40A(2)(b) – the person has to be the beneficial owner of the
shares and those very shares have to carry not less than 20% of the
voting power; Rejects Revenue’s clubbing of HDFC Ltd’s direct shareholding of
16.39% with indirect shareholding of 6.25% in assessee (through its wholly
owned subsidiary HDFC Investments Ltd) to establish ‘substantial
interest’; Holds that “….This would be contrary to all canons of Company
Law….It is well settled that a shareholder of a company can never be construed
either the legal or beneficial owner of the properties and assets of the
company”, relies on SC rulings in Bacha F. Guzdar and Vodafone International
Holdings BV; Further, noting that the transaction was a purchase of ‘asset’
reflected in the Balance Sheet and not in the P&L account, HC opines
that “Acquisition of an asset…cannot be said to be in the nature of an
expenditure so as to come within the ambit of section 92BA (i)"; HC also
holds that assessee’s payment to HBL Global for rendering services does not
qualify as SDT absent assessee holding ‘substantial interest’ in HBL Global,
rejects consideration of indirect shareholding in HBL Global; Also rejects
Revenue’s reliance on CBDT Circular dated July 6, 1968 and relies on ICAI
Guidance Note u/s 92E; HC also holds that assessee’s interest payment to HDB
Welfare would not fall within Sec 40A(2)(b) read with Explanation (b) as the
Trust was exclusively set up for the welfare of its employees and there was no
question of assessee being entitled to 20% of the profits of such Trust,
rejects Revenue’s reliance on Karnataka HC ruling in Amco Power Systems and SC
ruling in Podar Cement as ‘wholly misplaced’:HC
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Expenses Where Taxpayers May Revisit Their GST ITC Eligibility
Lease of Land ITC is blocked on goods and services used for construction of immovable property. However, land itself is not used for constru...
-
A new website launched for TDS related matters www.tdscpc.gov.in TRACES – T DS R econciliation A nalysis and C orrection E nabling S yste...
-
Slump sale is transfer of one or more business undertakings for a lump sum consideration, without assigning individual values to the each...
-
Key features of File Validation Utility (FVU) version 3.3 FVU 3.3 will be applicable for quarterly TDS/ TCS statements pertaining to...
-
CIT vs. The Instalment Supply Ltd (Delhi High Court) The assessee bought 1614 items of computer systems for Rs.40 lacs from HCL Hewlett ...
-
In a recent informal guidance letter, SEBI clarified whether a cousin of a Promoter Group member qualifies as a person ‘related to promote...
-
Facts The applicant („A‟) is a closely held Public Limited company incorporated in India in the year 1953. A‟s shareholder included A (...
-
01. TDS u/s 194J is required to be done for Royalty also w.e.f 13-7-2006. 02. Royalty had been defined under explanation 2 of se...
-
The benefit of interest free loan or loan at concessional rate of interest is given to an employee (or to any member of his household) is ...
-
Until now, 'Samaritans' is not how the Independent Directors are purported by Clause 49 in the Listing agreement. An Independ...
-
Facts Centrica India Offshore Private Limited (CIO), an Indian Company, is a wholly owned subsidiary of Centrica Plc, UK Centrica Plc a...
No comments:
Post a Comment